
In-house vs agency vs freelancer: who should maintain your website?
Every business website needs someone to keep it updated, secure and working. The choice is usually between someone on your team, a freelancer, or an agency. Each can work well. Each also fails in a typical way. Here is how they compare, so you can choose with your eyes open.
What the job actually involves
Before comparing who does it, be clear about what "maintenance" means. For a typical WordPress business website, it covers:
- Updating WordPress, themes and plugins, and testing that nothing broke.
- Keeping the server software, such as PHP, on supported versions.
- Running and testing backups.
- Watching for downtime, malware and suspicious logins.
- Fixing things when they break, sometimes urgently.
- Making small changes to content and design.
Some of this is routine. Some of it happens at the worst possible moment. Whoever you choose needs to handle both.
Option 1: In-house
Someone on your team, often from marketing or IT, looks after the website alongside other duties. Larger companies may have a dedicated web developer.
Pros
- Knows the business, the brand and the people.
- Available for quick content changes.
- No external contract to manage.
Cons
- Website care competes with their main job, so updates slip.
- Rarely has deep skills in servers, security and troubleshooting.
- Holidays and sick days leave nobody covering.
- When they leave, the knowledge often leaves with them.
- A dedicated developer is a significant salary for a job that may not fill their week.
Works best when: you have a full-time web person with real technical skills, or your website is simple and changes rarely.
Option 2: Freelancer
An independent developer who built your site, or one you found later, looks after it on an hourly or monthly basis.
Pros
- Often good value for the hours worked.
- A direct relationship with the person doing the work.
- Flexible and quick to start.
Cons
- One person means one point of failure: holidays, illness, a busy month or a career change.
- Skills vary widely, especially on hosting and security.
- Response times may depend on their other clients.
- Access and passwords sometimes live only with them.
Works best when: the freelancer is experienced, documents what they do, and you hold all the admin access yourself.
Option 3: Agency
A team provides website management as a service, usually on a monthly plan with defined tasks and response times. Some also provide hosting.
Pros
- A team, so someone is always available.
- Broader skills: development, servers, security, design and SEO.
- Processes for testing updates, backups and monitoring.
- Clear scope and reporting.
Cons
- Usually a higher monthly fee than a freelancer.
- Can feel less personal if you are passed between people.
- Small requests may need to go through a ticket or request form.
Works best when: the website matters to revenue, you want reliability more than the lowest price, and you prefer one team handling both website and hosting.
Side by side
| In-house | Freelancer | Agency | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost | Part of a salary, or a full salary | Lower monthly fee or hourly | Fixed monthly plan |
| Availability | Office hours, when not busy | Depends on one person | Team cover |
| Technical depth | Varies, often limited | Varies widely | Broad |
| Knowledge of your business | High | Medium | Medium, grows over time |
| Risk if they leave | High | High | Low |
| Process and reporting | Usually informal | Varies | Defined |
The hybrid that often works best
Many businesses split the job. Someone in-house handles content: new articles, team photos, prices, offers. An agency handles the technical side: updates, security, backups, hosting and anything that breaks. Your team keeps control of the message, and nobody has to learn server administration.
Questions to ask whoever you choose
- How often do you apply updates, and do you test them on staging first?
- Where are backups stored, and when did you last test a restore?
- Who covers when you are away?
- How quickly do you respond if the site goes down?
- Do we keep full admin access to the website, hosting and domain?
- What is included in the fee, and what is billed separately?
- Is there a minimum contract?
Counting the real cost
Comparing monthly fees alone is misleading. When you weigh the options, include the costs that do not appear on an invoice:
- Time: the hours an employee spends on updates and troubleshooting are hours not spent on their real job.
- Delay: a fix that waits until a freelancer is free, or until your colleague is back from holiday, can cost enquiries or sales in the meantime.
- Risk: skipped updates, untested backups or a missed malware infection can turn into a far bigger bill later, including lost search rankings if Google flags the site.
- Knowledge: if everything lives in one person's head, the cost of them leaving includes rebuilding that knowledge from scratch.
Put a rough number on what one day of your website being down or broken would cost. It makes the comparison much clearer.
Signs it is time to change
- Updates are months behind, and nobody is sure whether it is safe to apply them.
- You found out about downtime or a hack from a customer.
- Small changes take weeks because the person responsible is busy elsewhere.
- You do not know where your backups are, or whether they work.
- Your website, hosting and domain logins are held by someone outside the company.
Any one of these is a good reason to review how your website is looked after.
Switching without disruption
Changing who maintains your site does not have to be painful. Start by collecting every login: domain registrar, DNS, hosting, website admin, analytics and any premium plugin accounts. Ask the current person for a short handover note covering anything unusual about the setup. A new provider should then take a full backup, audit the site, and fix urgent issues first before moving to a regular schedule. If the hosting is also changing, plan the move carefully; our guide to website migration without downtime explains how.
Non-negotiables, whoever you choose
- Your company owns the domain, hosting account and admin logins.
- Passwords are stored in a shared password manager, not in one person's head.
- There is a written list of what is done each month.
- Backups are offsite and tested.
How we fit in
We provide website management as a team, month-to-month, with tested updates, offsite backups, monitoring and support, plus a free audit to start. We are happy to work alongside your in-house marketing person, or to take over from a freelancer who is moving on. With our managed hosting, the server is covered too.